跳到正文
CourtListener· Court of Chancery of Delaware·· 4 天前精选AI 评分65

特拉华衡平法院裁定律师用 GenAI 编造引文违反 Rule 11,签字律师个人被罚 2500 美元

Kevin Leiske v. Robert Gregory Kidd

AI 导读

特拉华州衡平法院 11 月 13 日就 Kevin Leiske 诉 Robert Gregory Kidd 案作出裁定,原告首席律师在答复简报中使用未获律所批准的 Perplexity Enterprise 起草内容,带入虚构引文和错误判例描述,违反 Rule 11(b)(2)。

变化判断

特拉华州衡平法院认定律师用 GenAI 生成虚构引文违反 Rule 11,签字律师个人罚 2500 美元,律所因已有 GenAI 政策与培训免于连带责任。

正文 · 原文

Jump To

Support FLP

CourtListener is a project of Free Law Project, a federally-recognized 501(c)(3) non-profit. Members help support our work and get special access to features.

Please become a member today.

Join Free.law Now

Nov. 13, 2026

Get Citation AlertsToggle Dropdown

Download PDF

Add Note

Kevin Leiske v. Robert Gregory Kidd

Court of Chancery of Delaware

Combined Opinion


                          COURT OF CHANCERY  
                                OF THE  
                          STATE OF DELAWARE  

LORI W. WILL LEONARD L. WILLIAMS JUSTICE CENTER
VICE CHANCELLOR 500 N. KING STREET, SUITE 11400
WILMINGTON, DELAWARE 19801-3734
November 13, 2026

Richard P. Rollo, Esquire Margaret M. DiBianca, Esquire
Travis S. Hunter, Esquire DiBianca Law, LLC
Richards, Layton & Finger, P.A. 1201 North Orange Street, Suite 504
920 North King Street Wilmington, Delaware 19801
Wilmington, Delaware 19801

  RE:    Kevin Leiske et al. v. Robert Gregory Kidd et al.,  
         C.A. No. 2025-0426-CDW (LWW)  

Dear Counsel,

  This letter resolves an Order to Show Cause concerning the misuse of  

generative artificial intelligence (“GenAI”). The plaintiffs submitted fabricated

quotations and mischaracterized legal authorities in a brief filed with this court.

After the defendants identified these errors, the plaintiffs’ counsel acknowledged

using a GenAI tool without verifying its output and filed a corrected brief that

removed the quotation marks but retained inaccurate legal propositions. I ordered

the partner who signed the brief and his law firm to show cause why sanctions should

not issue.

  The use of GenAI in legal practice is neither forbidden nor inherently  

problematic. Practitioners are increasingly turning to these tools, which offer

substantial benefits and opportunities for efficiency. But counsel must use them with
C.A. No. 2025-0426-CDW (LWW)
November 13, 2026
Page 2 of 13

the care required by Court of Chancery Rule 11 and the Delaware Lawyers’ Rules

of Professional Conduct. That obligation includes ensuring the accuracy of each

authority and citation presented to the court.

     That care was lacking here. Counsel failed to verify the accuracy of the  

answering brief despite his law firm’s comprehensive GenAI policy and mandatory

ethics training. Given the firm’s commendable efforts to prevent GenAI misuse, I

decline to sanction it. Counsel—who has since accepted full responsibility and

expressed sincere contrition—is sanctioned $2,500 under Rule 11, payable

personally to the Court of Chancery.

I. BACKGROUND

     On January 22, 2026, the plaintiffs filed an answering brief opposing the  

defendants’ exceptions to a Magistrate in Chancery’s final report on advancement.1

Five days later, the defendants’ reply brief identified that the answering brief

contained fabricated quotations, inaccurate citations, and hallucinated legal

propositions.2

     On January 28, plaintiffs’ lead counsel—the signatory on the brief—filed a  

letter acknowledging that a GenAI tool had been used to revise the brief, and

1
Pls.’ Answering Br. in Opp’n to Defs.’ Exceptions (Dkt. 62).
2
Reply Br. in Further Supp. of Defs.’ Exceptions to Magistrate’s Jan. 2, 2026 Report
(Dkt. 65) 12-13 nn. 4-6, 16 n.7.
C.A. No. 2025-0426-CDW (LWW)
November 13, 2026
Page 3 of 13

submitted a corrected answering brief.3 That letter attributed the failure to catch the

fabricated quotations and citation errors to an oversight during a paralegal’s cite-

check.4 Although the corrected brief removed quotation marks around the

nonexistent quotes, it retained the inaccurate descriptions of the underlying cases.5

After the defendants’ counsel filed a letter detailing these remaining

misrepresentations, the plaintiffs’ lead counsel responded on January 29 by faulting

opposing counsel for failing to “meet and confer” before alerting the court and

insisting that the cited authorities “are real” and “support the arguments advanced.”6

     On February 2, I overruled the defendants’ exceptions and affirmed the  

Magistrate’s final report on the merits, while retaining jurisdiction to address the

GenAI errors in the plaintiffs’ brief.7 On July 1, after further merits-based

proceedings, I entered an Order to Show Cause directing the plaintiffs’ lead counsel

and his law firm to explain why sanctions should not issue under Rule 11(c) and this

3
Letter Providing Corrected Answering Br. in Opp’n to Defs.’ Exceptions (Dkt. 68); Pls.’
Corrected Answering Br. in Opp’n to Defs.’ Exceptions (Dkt. 69) (“Pls.’ Corrected
Answering Br.”).
4
Letter Providing Corrected Answering Br. in Opp’n to Defs.’ Exceptions (Dkt. 68) 2.
5
See Letter in Resp. to Pls.’ Letter Regarding GenAI Errors (Dkt. 70) 1-2 (asserting that
the corrected brief “merely fixes citation errors as if they are typographical only” and “still
mischaracterizes some of the Courts’ analyses”).
6
Letter in Resp. to Defs.’ Jan. 28 Letter (Dkt. 71) 1-2.
7
Letter Op. Resolving Exceptions (Dkt. 74) 7 n.40.
C.A. No. 2025-0426-CDW (LWW)
November 13, 2026
Page 4 of 13

court’s inherent authority.8 Richard Rollo, Esq., on his own behalf, and Paul N.

Heath, Esq., on behalf of Richards, Layton & Finger, P.A. (“RLF”), filed detailed

affidavits in response to that Order.9 Having reviewed those affidavits, I conclude

that a separate evidentiary hearing is unnecessary and that the matter can be resolved

on the papers.10

II. ANALYSIS

     Under Rule 11(b)(2), an attorney presenting “a pleading, written motion, or  

other paper” to the court certifies that “to the best of the person’s knowledge,

information, and belief, formed after an inquiry reasonable under the

circumstances,” the “legal contentions” made “are warranted by existing law.”11

“An attorney’s signature on a court filing is not a procedural formality; it is a

certification to the tribunal.”12 A fake quotation or a fabricated legal synthesis

8
Letter Order to Show Cause Why Sanctions Should Not Issue (Dkt. 102) (“Rule 11 Letter
Order”) 6-8 (specifying what the affidavits from counsel and the firm must include).
9
Aff. of R. Rollo, Esq. (Dkt. 103) (“Rollo Aff.”); Aff. of P. Heath, Esq. (Dkt. 103) (“Heath
Aff.”).
10
See Hill v. Workday, Inc., 2026 WL 1146289, at *4 (N.D. Cal. Apr. 28, 2026) (observing
that a separate sanctions hearing is not required when counsel gets a chance to respond in
writing) (citing Pac. Harbor Cap., Inc. v. Carnival Air Lines, Inc., 210 F.3d 1112, 1118
(9th Cir. 2000)).
11
Ct. Ch. R. 11(b)(2).
12
Rule 11 Letter Order 4 (citing Crumplar v. Superior Ct. ex rel. New Castle Cnty., 56 A.3d 1000, 1005-06 (Del. 2012)).
C.A. No. 2025-0426-CDW (LWW)
November 13, 2026
Page 5 of 13

generated by an algorithm is not “existing law,” and presenting unverified GenAI

output to a court violates Rule 11(b)(2).13

     A.     Law Firm Responsibility Under Rule 11  

     Rule 11(c)(1) mandates that “[a]bsent exceptional circumstances, a law firm  

must be held jointly responsible for violations committed by its partners, associates,

or employees.”14 In determining whether a law firm should be relieved of joint

responsibility for a lawyer’s Rule 11 violation, professional conduct standards

governing law firm management provide useful guidance. Under Delaware

Lawyers’ Rule of Professional Conduct 5.1(a), law firm leadership must make

reasonable efforts to ensure that the firm has measures in effect giving reasonable

assurance that all lawyers conform to those rules.15 Consistent with that principle,

ABA Formal Opinion 512 instructs “[m]anagerial lawyers” to “establish clear

policies regarding the law firm’s permissible use of G[en]AI” and “supervisory

13
Ct. Ch. R. 11(b)(2); see Mata v. Avianca, Inc., 678 F. Supp. 3d 443, 461 (S.D.N.Y. 2023)
(“A fake opinion is not ‘existing law’ . . . .”); see also Lexos Media IP, LLC v.
Overstock.com, Inc., 2026 WL 265581, at *10 (D. Kan. Feb. 2, 2026) (“There is no
question that citing to a nonexistent case, attributing a nonexistent quotation to an existing
case, and misstating the law violates Rule 11(b).”).
14
Ct. Ch. R. 11(c)(1).
15
Del. Lawyers’ Rules of Prof. Conduct R. 5.1(a) (“A partner in a law firm, and a lawyer
who individually or together with other lawyers possesses comparable managerial
authority in a law firm, shall make reasonable efforts to ensure that the firm has in effect
measures giving reasonable assurance that all lawyers in the firm conform to the Rules of
Professional Conduct.”).
C.A. No. 2025-0426-CDW (LWW)
November 13, 2026
Page 6 of 13

lawyers” to “make reasonable efforts to ensure that the firm’s lawyers and

nonlawyers comply with their professional obligations when using G[en]AI tools.”16

      RLF has demonstrated exceptional circumstances relieving it of joint  

responsibility. Its response to the emergence of GenAI reflects substantial

institutional efforts to prevent the very problem at issue. RLF barred the use of

unapproved GenAI tools in March 2023.17 In 2024, the firm formed a working group

of directors and professional staff to evaluate GenAI tools and study ethical

guidance, including ABA Formal Opinion 512.18 In July 2025, RLF’s Board of

Directors adopted a comprehensive Generative Artificial Intelligence Policy.19 The

policy requires an experienced lawyer to review GenAI output for accuracy and

completeness and prohibits its use as a substitute for independent judgment or legal

analysis.20 RLF also developed an internal training program addressing

hallucinations, ABA Formal Opinion 512, and professional obligations concerning

competence, confidentiality, meritorious claims, candor, and supervision.21 The

16
ABA Comm. on Ethics & Prof. Resp., Formal Op. 512, at 10 (2024); see Lexos Media,
2026 WL 265581, at *16.
17
Heath Aff. ¶ 8.
18
Id. ¶¶ 9-14.
19
Id. ¶ 15.
20
Id. ¶¶ 15-16.
21
Id. ¶¶ 23, 25-28.
C.A. No. 2025-0426-CDW (LWW)
November 13, 2026
Page 7 of 13

program was accredited for one hour of Enhanced Ethics credit by Delaware’s

Commission on Continuing Legal Education and completed by over 200 RLF

employees by January 2026.22

     In short, RLF did the right thing. It warned of GenAI risks, established clear  

verification policies, and trained its personnel through a substantial, multi-layered

approach. RLF acted reasonably to prevent GenAI misuse and should not be

sanctioned for an individual lawyer bypassing those controls.23 These safeguards

were in place before the offending brief was filed. RLF is therefore released from

this proceeding without sanction.

     B.      Individual Responsibility Under Rule 11  

     Rule 11(c)(1) authorizes the court to impose an appropriate sanction on “any  

attorney . . . that violated [Rule 11(b)] or is responsible for the violation.” 24 The

rule’s certification requirement reinforces a lawyer’s ethical duty of candor toward

the tribunal under Delaware Lawyers’ Rule of Professional Conduct 3.3(a)(1) and

22
Id. ¶¶ 24, 29.
23
See Johnson v. Dunn, 792 F. Supp. 3d 1241, 1260-62 (N.D. Ala. 2025) (declining to
sanction a law firm under the court’s inherent authority where the firm had warned
attorneys of hallucination risks, required permission and independent verification for
GenAI use, and strengthened its safeguards after discovering the misconduct, finding that
the firm “acted reasonably in its efforts to prevent this misconduct” when a partner misused
GenAI).
24
Ct. Ch. R. 11(c)(1).
C.A. No. 2025-0426-CDW (LWW)
November 13, 2026
Page 8 of 13

the duty to supervise nonlawyer assistants under Rule 5.3.25 As ABA Formal

Opinion 512 emphasizes, a lawyer may not delegate professional judgment to a

GenAI tool and remains responsible for verifying all work product before it is filed.26

     The affidavit of plaintiffs’ lead counsel candidly explains how the errors  

occurred. As Chair of RLF’s AI Subcommittee, he was leading a pilot evaluation of

Perplexity Enterprise, a tool that had not been approved for general firm use. 27 He

used the tool to help draft and condense arguments in the answering brief. That

process introduced fabricated quotations, flawed citations, and a mischaracterized

case holding into the text.28 He then delegated citation checking to a junior attorney

and a paralegal and filed the brief without personally verifying the authorities or

checking the citations and quotations after that review.29

     Three points warrant emphasis.  

     First, the duty of candor to the court and the obligation to conduct a reasonable  

inquiry under Rule 11 are personal and nondelegable.30 Although practitioners

25
Del. Lawyers’ Rules of Prof. Conduct R. 3.3(a)(1), 5.3.
26
ABA Comm. on Ethics & Pro. Resp., Formal Op. 512, at 3-4, 10 (2024).
27
Rollo Aff. ¶¶ 9, 25; see also Heath Aff. ¶¶ 17, 19, 33-34.
28
Rollo Aff. ¶¶ 10-13.
29
Id. ¶¶ 14-16.
30
See Pavelic & LeFlore v. Marvel Ent. Grp., 493 U.S. 120, 126 (1989) (“[T]he purpose
of Rule 11 as a whole is to bring home to the individual signer his personal, nondelegable
C.A. No. 2025-0426-CDW (LWW)
November 13, 2026
Page 9 of 13

routinely and appropriately rely on skilled paralegals and junior attorneys for cite-

checking, a senior attorney who signs a brief cannot disclaim responsibility when

unverified GenAI output is submitted to the court.31 When an attorney knowingly

introduces text produced by GenAI into a draft, the signatory must ensure that the

underlying authorities have been reviewed and support the propositions for which

they are cited.

  Second, it is no excuse that the cases cited are real decisions or that the  

overarching legal propositions are arguably consistent with general principles of

law. GenAI tools do not only invent case captions. They also fabricate plausible-

sounding quotations or stretch a real decision to stand for a proposition it never

addressed.32 That existing law may generally support a party’s ultimate position

responsibility.”); Lexos Media, 2026 WL 265581, at *9 (noting that the Rule 11 duty to
conduct a reasonable inquiry into existing law is “nondelegable”).
31
See Hill, 2026 WL 1146289, at *3, *8 (“The duty to check every paper filed in court for
accuracy and veracity is nondelegable to other attorneys or to technology.” (citation
omitted)); In re Kenney, 422 So. 3d 905, 913, 920-21 (La. Ct. App. 2025) (affirming
sanctions against counsel who relied on paralegals to check citations but failed to
independently verify AI-generated authorities against actual judicial opinions); see also
Noland v. Land of the Free, L.P., 336 Cal. Rptr. 3d 897, 901 (Ct. App. 2025) (“[N]o brief,
pleading, motion, or any other paper filed in any court should contain any citations—
whether provided by generative AI or any other source—that the attorney responsible for
submitting the pleading has not personally read and verified.”).
32
See, e.g., Lexos Media, 2026 WL 265581, at *2-5 (detailing GenAI hallucinations
involving fabricated quotations attributed to actual decisions and mischaracterizations of
their holdings); Hill, 2026 WL 1146289, at *2 (addressing a brief that cited a nonexistent
case and misrepresented the holding of an actual decision); Wilson v. Kipp Texas, Inc.,
C.A. No. 2025-0426-CDW (LWW)
November 13, 2026
Page 10 of 13

does not excuse the submission of fabricated quotations or mischaracterized

holdings.33 If GenAI errors are detected, counsel has an affirmative duty to review

the underlying authorities and correct any inaccurate quotations or characterizations.

It is not enough to remove quotation marks and leave a fabricated legal synthesis in

place.34

     Third, as explained in the Order to Show Cause, faulting opposing counsel for  

failing to “meet and confer” before alerting the court to GenAI errors misstates the

purpose of that requirement.35 There is nothing to negotiate when false citations or

2025 WL 3030444, at *3 (N.D. Tex. Oct. 29, 2025) (sanctioning counsel for presenting
GenAI-fabricated statements as verbatim quotations in a court filing).
33
See Johnson, 792 F. Supp. 3d at 1262 (rejecting an argument that sanctions should be
minimal because “actual authorities stand for the proposition that the bogus authorities
were offered to support,” and noting that “any sanctions discount on this basis would
amplify the siren call of unverified AI for lawyers who are already confident in their legal
conclusion”); Lexos Media, 2026 WL 265581, at *3-5, *13-14 (sanctioning counsel where
a brief attributed nonexistent quotations and holdings to real precedent and rejecting
counsel’s attempt to downplay the errors by claiming that the brief was overwhelmingly
human-drafted).
34
See Mata, 678 F. Supp. 3d at 461, 464 (noting that Rule 11 obligations continue when
“later advocating” a prior filing and sanctioning counsel who continued to defend
fabricated authorities after opposing counsel flagged them); Hill, 2026 WL 1146289, at *3
(“Upon detection of fabricated or erroneous citations, an attorney has an affirmative,
personal, non-delegable duty to review all citations for accuracy and validity and to correct
them . . . .” (citing Kenney, 422 So. 3d at 915-16, 920-21)).
35
Rule 11 Letter Order 5-6.
C.A. No. 2025-0426-CDW (LWW)
November 13, 2026
Page 11 of 13

fabricated quotations are presented to a tribunal. Opposing counsel was fully

justified in bringing such errors directly to the court’s attention.36

   C.     Sanctions  

   A Rule 11 sanction “must be limited to what suffices to deter repetition of the  

conduct or comparable conduct by others similarly situated.”37 The purpose of such

a sanction is to vindicate judicial authority and deter carelessness—not to punish or

compensate litigants.38

   In setting an appropriate sanction, I consider the specific circumstances of this  

case. On the one hand, plaintiffs’ lead counsel initially shifted blame to a paralegal

and, even after removing quotation marks, retained the inaccurate characterizations

36
On August 4, 2026, the defendants’ counsel filed a letter requesting leave to present
billing records and information about the plaintiffs’ counsel’s time records. Letter from
M. DiBianca (Dkt. 104). That request is denied. Because this Rule 11 inquiry was initiated
sua sponte to address misconduct affecting the court, rather than on a motion for sanctions,
an award of attorneys’ fees is unavailable under Rule 11. See Ct. Ch. R. 11(c)(4); Lexos
Media, 2026 WL 265581, at *7 n.63; Mata, 678 F. Supp. 3d at 465-66. Because the
plaintiffs’ counsel has acknowledged the Rule 11 violation under oath and I credit the
sworn affidavits submitted in response to the Order to Show Cause, inviting opposing
counsel to raise purported discrepancies in billing records would serve no useful purpose.
37
Ct. Ch. R. 11(c)(4); accord Fed. R. Civ. P. 11(c)(4); see also Cooter & Gell v. Hartmarx
Corp., 496 U.S. 384, 393 (1990) (identifying deterrence as Rule 11’s central purpose).
38
See Mata, 678 F. Supp. 3d at 466 (“An attorney may be required to pay a fine, or, in the
words of Rule 11, a ‘penalty,’ to advance the interests of deterrence and not as punishment
or compensation.” (citing Universitas Educ., LLC v. Nova Grp., Inc., 784 F.3d 99, 103-04
(2d Cir. 2015))); Johnson, 792 F. Supp. 3d at 1265-66 (emphasizing deterrence and
vindicating judicial authority in fashioning sanctions under the court’s inherent power).
C.A. No. 2025-0426-CDW (LWW)
November 13, 2026
Page 12 of 13

of legal authority. On the other hand, in his affidavit, counsel accepted full

responsibility for the filings, disavowed any suggestion that others were to blame,

and expressed sincere contrition.39 He has practiced before this court with

distinction for years.40 And because he has completed multiple CLE courses on

GenAI ethics and leads internal training efforts, ordering additional mandatory CLE

would be redundant.41

      Consistent with the range of monetary penalties imposed by courts in similar  

sua sponte Rule 11 proceedings, the plaintiffs’ lead counsel is sanctioned in the

amount of $2,500.42 Given the nondelegable nature of Rule 11’s verification

39
Rollo Aff. ¶¶ 3-5, 22, 30.
40
Id. ¶¶ 1, 30.
41
Id. ¶¶ 24-26; see Mata, 678 F. Supp. 3d at 466 (concluding that because counsel’s firm
had arranged mandatory CLE training on technological competence and AI tools,
“[i]mposing a sanction of further and additional mandatory education would be
redundant”).
42
See, e.g., Gill v. Everyday Dose, Inc., 2026 WL 3390881, at *5-7 (D. Del. Nov. 9, 2026)
(imposing $3,000 fines on two attorneys who submitted AI-hallucinated authorities and
deflected responsibility for the errors); Jimenez-Fogarty v. Fogarty, 831 F. Supp. 3d 253,
266-68 (S.D.N.Y. 2026) (imposing a $2,500 fine in a sua sponte Rule 11 proceeding);
Wadsworth v. Walmart Inc., 348 F.R.D. 489, 498-99 (D. Wyo. 2025) (imposing a $3,000
fine on counsel who drafted a filing containing fabricated authorities); Mattox v. Prod.
Innovations Rsch., LLC, 807 F. Supp. 3d 1341, 1351-52 (E.D. Okla. 2025) (imposing
graduated fines of $3,000, $2,000, and $1,000 based on counsel’s respective
responsibilities); Benjamin v. Costco Wholesale Corp., 779 F. Supp. 3d 341, 351 (E.D.N.Y.
2025) (imposing a $1,000 fine after considering counsel’s remorse and remedial AI
training).
C.A. No. 2025-0426-CDW (LWW)
November 13, 2026
Page 13 of 13

requirement, he must personally pay this amount to the court within 14 days of this

decision.43 He must also file an affidavit confirming payment upon completion.

   IT IS SO ORDERED.  

                                             Sincerely yours,  

                                             /s/ Lori W. Will  

                                             Lori W. Will  
                                             Vice Chancellor  

43
See Hill, 2026 WL 1146289, at *9 (ordering sanctioned partner to “pay this amount
directly and personally (and this amount shall not be paid by the . . . law firm)”); Ct. Ch.
R. 11(c)(4).

Newsletter

Sign up to receive the Free Law Project newsletter with tips and announcements.

来源:CourtListener · courtlistener.com