404 Media 调查:AI 内容农场用 500 个频道冒领版权,真人音乐人申诉无门
AI-Powered Copyright Hell
404 Media 的 Matthew Gault 报道,音乐人 Samantha Shokin 翻唱的保加利亚民歌《Bre Petrunko》被 Media Nov Records 发起版权投诉,YouTube 自动下架了她的原视频,她两次提交反通知都被驳回,YouTube 回复称无法确认她有正当理由。

Happy Monday, everybody. We hope you didn't get stranded this weekend. This is looking to be quite a busy week, what with the tech-related airplane grounding and all. To get things started, we have a story from Matthew Gault about a human singer whose work got caught in an AI-generated copyright hell.
How an AI Content Mill Put a Real Musician Through Copyright Hell
When writer and musician Samantha Shokin noticed her cover of a public domain Bulgarian folk song had been copyright struck on YouTube, she assumed it would be easy to fix. It wasn’t. And trying to figure out what happened led her to discover an AI content mill that is running 500 slop-filled channels and abusing YouTube’s automated copyright detectors.
“Any human would agree with me that there’s something clearly wrong here that needs to be fixed, but I can’t get in touch with a human being,” Shokin said.
Shokin’s journey is a modern nightmare that highlights the ways AI can be weaponized against human creators, and the ways people fall through the cracks of big tech’s automated systems.
During the pandemic, Shokin recorded a 50 second version of the Bulgarian folk song ‘Bre Petrunko’ and uploaded it to SoundCloud, where it didn’t get much traction. Two years later, she uploaded it to YouTube and watched as her cover grew in popularity, gaining 125,000 views in four years.
Last summer, she noticed an uptick in comments on the video. Unbeknownst to Shokin, her version of “Bre Petruinko” had become popular among DJs and electronic artists and had been sampled in dozens of songs. Someone in the comments pointed her towards one of the more popular tracks. “I look up this video and it’s something that has millions of hits [...] and 30 seconds into this track I hear my own voice and I was utterly shocked. I didn’t know how to react,” she said (the video has more than 4 million views).
“The first thing that comes to mind is, ‘Oh my god, someone stole my voice and didn’t credit me,’” she said. Shokin said she talked to a lot of DJs and figured out how they’d gotten her voice. They’d purchased a pack of samples from a company called Loopmasters that was selling her version of “Bre Petruinko” as part of its “Folk Legends” set.
“I got in touch with the distributor and they were deeply apologetic. They were unaware that this had happened and they immediately tried to make right of the situation and granted me royalties on the sample pack,” Shokin said. “At that point, countless DJs and music producers had been using my voice for their own tracks, unbeknownst to me. At least I’m aware and at least I was making something off of it and I was satisfied with that. I didn’t love the way that it came about, but whatever, they tried to make right of the situation.”
But Shokin’s “Bre Petruinko” saga wasn’t over. Last month, she opened YouTube and noticed her original recording was gone. A company called Media Nov Records had issued a copyright strike against her song, and YouTube had taken it down. She thought it would be easy to get this reversed. It’s a public domain folk song and she had the original recordings and a history with a distributor. “If I just explain it to YouTube, they’ll understand,” she thought.
Media Nov Records advertises itself as a “distribution company” that that partners with artists to release their music on digital platforms. But a lot of its website focuses on rights management and copyright protection. “At Media Nov, we go above and beyond to safeguard your musical creations. Our comprehensive rights management system leverages cutting-edge technology and legal expertise to ensure you receive the royalties you deserve,” it said on its website.
YouTube uses automated systems to work through copyright claims. When someone files a claim against a video, the company tends to automatically approve it. The original uploader can file a “counterclaim,” where they argue that the video should stay up, or that it should not be demonetized.
Shokin filed two counterclaims, but neither worked. “It's unclear to us whether you have a valid reason for filing a counter notification, so we won't be able to honor your request,” YouTube said in its last denial. It told her to contact the copyright holder; in this case, it was a public domain song and so there was no actual “copyright holder,” just Media Nov, which was claiming to hold it.
“I tried emailing them,” she said. “I tried calling them. There doesn’t appear to be a working phone line. I got in touch with [Loopmaster, which was selling her recording]. They tried getting in touch. I’m being ignored by everybody, by YouTube, by this media company that, like, the website seems to be entirely AI-generated, and all I want is to talk to a human about this.”
Read the rest of the article here.
More from 404

This Comic Kills Technofascists: We had a wonderful Q&A from our friend Dave Maass over the weekend about Exploit, Laura Hudson’s new comic about independent journalists who take on technofascists. We’ll be experimenting here and there with more tech culture coverage so let us know what you’re into
AI and Nuclear War: In the interview pod this week, Matt talks to Ankit Panda, author of The New Nuclear Age, about how AI is affecting how experts consider nuclear war and the nuclear threat more broadly.

MERCH! We have some new merch! We finally made our very popular 404 ‘Doom Code’ tank tops and long sleeve shirts in short sleeve t-shirt form. Now available in all sleeve configurations. And we’ve now got a trucker hat, too. We’re slowly working our way through redoing our merch, so expect some new designs in the coming weeks, though probably not in time for the holidays (oops).
Around the web
Flightpocalypse Now: Everyone I know has asked me about the FAA’s ground stop Friday, and has asked what happened and if I’m going to report on it. By the time the ground stop was issued, I had felt like I’d gotten hit by a bus, so the answer was basically: I don’t know and I’m going to bed! And that sort of seems to be the case for our administration, which insists this has nothing to do with AI and as of the time I’m writing this does not seem to have a definitive explanation for what happened, says no one is going to lose their jobs over this, and whose communication strategy has mainly seemed to be standing at a podium and yelling at people who are annoyed by the mass chaos of having every flight grounded. I’m not sure if we’ll have more coverage on this or not, but wow, what a mess. As of this morning, it’s looking like we’re blaming a router in Arkansas, which is now being studying in a “lab down in Florida,” the administration said. We have done some stuff in the part with flight tracking and have ambiently learned that our air traffic control system is a mess and the actual workers are exhausted, but unfortunately we’re not super well-sourced in this space. So we’ll keep an eye out, probably send some FOIAs, but not sure if we’ll be able to break any new ground here. As an emo, though, I must say I was thrilled to see the Hoobastank/Simple Plan/The Used Southwest Airlines mid-flight concert, then annoyed to learn it was a Warped Tour psy-op.
Nvidia saga drags on: Will Jensen Huang come back? Won’t he? What does Trump want? Tim Cook? Denny’s has officially repudiated Jensen Huang, OK? The CEO / spying saga at the world’s most valuable company is going to drag on for a bit, I’m sure. At the moment you are probably best served by asking someone to wake you when this is over.
RAM Collusion: A federal judge in California denied a motion to dismiss a class-action lawsuit against Micro, Samsung, and SK hynix that accuses them of collaborating to jack up the price of RAM, which has increased in price more than 500% in the last year or so as manufacturers pivot to selling to AI data centers rather than consumers. Speaking of jacked up prices, I was yammering in here the other day about how expensive Raspberry Pi prices have gotten. I enjoyed this blog about using an old phone as a Raspberry Pi stand-in instead. Used Android phones are pretty cheap. It’s a great idea.
Full 90: Google’s elite hacking team Project Zero says that in an effort to push software developers to patch their stuff faster, it will reduce the amount of time it gives them to fix a vulnerability before disclosing it to the public. Google says “vulnerabilities will be disclosed 90 days after they are reported to the vendor,” that early next year it will move to a 60-day policy, and that in 2028 it will move to a 30 day policy because “LLMs have increased the speed at which attackers can find and exploit vulnerabilities.” It also says “LLMs have also increased the volume of vulnerabilities that Project Zero reports. We are finding several vulnerabilities a week in targets where we once found a few vulnerabilities a year,” and that “Aspects of our policy that require vendor negotiation or agreement, including determining whether a bug is fixed and whether grace period applies, are quickly becoming unmanageable.”
Reverse Engineer Anything: This guy connected an Arduino to his 1994 Jeep Cherokee with no ODB2 port and then had Claude Code reverse engineer and control it. And some dorks made a chatbot that runs on MS-DOS, using a floppy disc.
来源:404 Media · 404media.co